Skip to content
All articles

Bulk, cut or recomp: which one should you do?

Forge team · · 5 min read

Short answer: if you're new to lifting or coming back after a long break, recomp. If you're carrying a lot of fat, cut first. If you're already lean and want more size, bulk, slowly. Most people who can't decide are in the first group and should recomp.

The three options in one table

All three only work if you're lifting regularly and eating enough protein. What changes is the calories.

Goal Calories Weight change per week What you're after
Cut about 20% under maintenance down 0.5 to 1% Lose fat, keep muscle
Recomp about 5% under maintenance roughly flat Lose fat and build muscle at the same time, slowly
Bulk about 10 to 20% over maintenance up 0.25 to 0.5% Build muscle as fast as is sensible, accepting some fat

The bulk numbers come from a review of nutrition for natural bodybuilders, which suggests a surplus of roughly 10 to 20% and a gain of about 0.25 to 0.5% of body weight per week for beginners and intermediates, and less for advanced lifters (Iraki et al., 2019). The cut numbers are explained in how big your calorie deficit should be.

What each one looks like for one person

Here's what the Forge macro calculator gives a 28-year-old man, 175 cm, 75 kg, training four times a week:

Goal Daily calories Daily protein
Maintain 2,650 kcal 135 g
Recomp 2,520 kcal 165 g
Cut 2,120 kcal 165 g
Bulk 3,050 kcal 135 g

Notice that protein is higher on a recomp and a cut than on a bulk. When you eat less, protein has more work to do in protecting muscle (why).

Recomp: the right default for most people

A recomposition means eating close to maintenance, training hard and keeping protein high, so you lose fat and gain muscle at the same time. Your weight barely moves, but your waist shrinks and your lifts go up.

For a long time recomping was thought to work only for beginners and people with a lot of fat to lose. A 2020 review found plenty of studies showing it in people who already train too, as long as two things are in place: progressive resistance training and good nutrition, especially enough protein (Barakat et al., 2020). It's slower than a dedicated bulk or cut, and it's hard to see on the scale, which is why people give up on it too early.

Recomp if you are:

  • New to lifting. Your first year is when your body responds fastest; you can build muscle on almost any sensible diet.
  • Returning after a break. Muscle you've built before comes back faster than it took to build.
  • Somewhere in the middle and not sure what you want: not lean, not carrying a lot of fat.
  • Happy with your weight but not with how you look at it.

Cut first if you have a lot of fat to lose

As a rough guide, that means above about 20% body fat for men or 30% for women. Without a scan: if you can pinch a thick fold at your belly and your waist is well over half your height, you're likely in this group.

Why cut first? You have plenty of stored energy to draw on, so a deficit costs you little muscle, and losing fat makes training, sleep and energy better. A bulk at this point mostly adds more fat. Once you're leaner, decide again. Keep lifting and keep protein high the whole way (how to lose fat without losing muscle).

Bulk if you're already lean and want size

As a rough guide, below about 12 to 15% body fat for men or 22 to 25% for women: you can see some outline of your abs, and your main goal is to get bigger and stronger.

  • Keep the surplus small. Gaining faster than about 0.5% of your body weight a week mostly adds fat, not extra muscle.
  • Track your waist as well as your weight. If your waist grows much faster than your lifts improve, the surplus is too big.
  • Give it time. Muscle grows slowly; a bulk is measured in months, not weeks.

The more experienced you are, the slower you'll gain muscle, so the smaller your surplus should be.

The mistakes behind most wasted years

  • Switching every few weeks. Two weeks of bulk, a panic, two weeks of cut. Pick one and commit for 8 to 12 weeks before you judge it.
  • "Dirty" bulking. A huge surplus doesn't build muscle faster. It just means a longer cut afterwards.
  • Cutting when you're already lean because you don't like a number on the scale. If you're lean and small, you need muscle, not less weight.
  • Judging a recomp by the scale. On a recomp the scale is supposed to stay still. Track your waist, your lifts and monthly photos instead.
  • Forgetting the training. Any of the three goes nowhere without progressive lifting. Diet decides the direction; training decides whether it's muscle.

The short version

  • New, returning, or in the middle: recomp. About 5% under maintenance, high protein.
  • Lots of fat (roughly men 20%+, women 30%+): cut. About 20% under, 0.5 to 1% a week.
  • Lean and want size (roughly men under 12 to 15%, women under 22 to 25%): bulk. About 10 to 20% over, 0.25 to 0.5% a week.
  • Commit for 8 to 12 weeks, judge by waist, lifts and photos as well as weight.

Choose your goal in the macro calculator to see your calories and protein for each.

General guidance for healthy adults, not medical advice. If you're under 18, pregnant, or have a history of disordered eating, talk to a doctor before changing how you eat.