Skip to content
All articles

How big should your calorie deficit be?

Forge team · · 4 min read

Short answer: eat about 20% below your maintenance calories, and aim to lose 0.5 to 1% of your body weight per week. The leaner you already are, the closer to 0.5% you should stay. Bigger deficits lose weight faster on paper, but more of that weight is muscle, and they're much harder to stick to.

Why the size of the deficit matters

Any deficit makes you lose weight. The question is what you lose. Your body can cover a shortfall from fat or from muscle, and the bigger the gap, the more it leans on muscle, especially if you're already fairly lean.

The clearest test of this was done with elite athletes who all lifted weights four times a week. One group dieted to lose 0.7% of their body weight per week, the other 1.4%. The slower group gained lean mass and strength while dieting; the faster group mostly didn't (Garthe et al., 2011). A review of the evidence for natural bodybuilders landed on the same range: set calories so you lose about 0.5 to 1% of body weight per week to hold on to muscle (Helms et al., 2014).

What different deficits look like

Take the same man from our other guides: 28 years old, 175 cm, 75 kg, training four times a week, with maintenance of 2,650 kcal. A kilo of body fat holds roughly 7,700 kcal, so the expected loss per week is the daily deficit × 7 ÷ 7,700:

Deficit Eat per day Daily deficit Expected loss per week % of his weight
10% 2,390 kcal 260 kcal about 0.24 kg 0.3%
15% 2,250 kcal 400 kcal about 0.36 kg 0.5%
20% 2,120 kcal 530 kcal about 0.48 kg 0.6%
25% 1,990 kcal 660 kcal about 0.60 kg 0.8%
30% 1,860 kcal 790 kcal about 0.72 kg 1.0%

The 20% row is what the Forge macro calculator uses for a cut. It sits in the middle of the 0.5 to 1% range: fast enough that the scale moves every week, slow enough that training still feels like training.

Treat the "expected loss" column as a direction, not a promise. The 7,700 kcal rule is a rough average, and as you lose weight your maintenance falls too, so progress slows unless you recalculate (why maintenance moves).

How to pick yours

  • Plenty of fat to lose? You can go towards 25% (about 1% a week). More stored fat means more to draw on, and less risk to muscle.
  • Average, or new to this? 20% is the safe default.
  • Already lean (visible abs, or close)? Stay near 10 to 15% (about 0.5% a week). This is where fast diets cost the most muscle.
  • Want to build muscle at the same time? That's a recomposition: a small deficit of about 5% and high protein. Forge has it as its own goal.

Whatever you pick, keep protein high (about 2.2 g per kg on a cut; see how much protein you need) and keep lifting. Those two do more to protect muscle than any fine-tuning of the deficit; the full list is in how to lose fat without losing muscle.

Signs your deficit is too big

  • After the first two weeks, you're losing more than 1% of your body weight a week.
  • Your lifts are dropping week after week, not just on a bad day.
  • You're sleeping badly, constantly cold, or thinking about food all day.
  • You keep breaking the diet at weekends and undoing the week.

Any two of these: add 100 to 200 kcal back, mostly from carbs, and reassess in two weeks. A slower diet you keep beats a fast one you abandon.

Signs it's too small (or not really there)

  • Your weekly average weight hasn't moved for three weeks.
  • You've been estimating portions rather than weighing them.

First check the logging: oils, sauces and drinks are where most untracked calories hide. If the logging is honest, take away 100 to 200 kcal and give it another two weeks.

Does taking breaks help?

Possibly. In one trial, men with obesity dieted in two-week blocks separated by two weeks at maintenance. Over the same total time spent dieting, they lost more fat than men who dieted without breaks, and their metabolism slowed less (Byrne et al., 2018). It was a small study, and breaks make the diet take longer overall. If you're months into a cut and struggling, a week or two at maintenance is a reasonable reset, not a failure.

How low is too low?

Don't go below your BMR as a habit, and don't treat very-low-calorie diets (around 800 kcal a day or less) as a DIY plan: they're a medical treatment and should be supervised by a doctor. Forge won't set a target below 1,000 kcal, because under that a sensible split of protein, carbs and fat stops being possible.

The short version

  • Start at 20% below maintenance.
  • Aim for 0.5 to 1% of body weight per week; closer to 0.5% if you're lean.
  • Keep protein high and keep lifting.
  • Judge by weekly averages over two weeks or more, then adjust by 100 to 200 kcal.
  • Losing faster than 1% a week, getting weaker, or can't stick to it: make the deficit smaller.

Want your number? The macro calculator works out your maintenance and the 20% cut in one go.

General guidance for healthy adults, not medical advice. If you have a history of disordered eating, are pregnant or breastfeeding, are under 18, or have a medical condition, talk to a doctor before dieting.